3 Confirmed New Legends in MLB The Show 24

1 min readFeb 28, 2024

Three new legends are coming to MLB The Show 24.

We’re gonna go over which season would return the best card.

Paul O’Neill

Let’s start with Paul O’Neill. O’Neill had some great years, but his best would be his 1994 season. The season was shorten, but within 103 games, he hit for a .359 with a ops over 1.000.

Bernie Williams

For Bernie Williams, it’s easily his ’98 season. He posted A .997 ops while batting .339 with 26 home runs and stealing 15 bases. Plus he had a gold glove to go on top of that.

Andy Pettitte

Andy Pettitte in 2005 with Astros, he won 17 games, posted a 2.39 ERA while striking over 170 batters and only walking 41.

Overall, we are excited for all three new legends coming to MLB The Show 24.